Understanding Trauma, Part 1: What Trauma Is, and What It Isn’t

The first of two posts on trauma, drawing on Judith Herman’s Trauma and Recovery.
Trauma has become a word that is commonly used. It names something real, and it has also stretched to cover almost any painful experience. Both of these are worth taking seriously. When the word is used loosely, people who have lived through overwhelming events can find their experience flattened. When it is used too narrowly, people whose suffering came slowly, inside relationships rather than in a single event, may not recognize themselves in it at all.
Judith Herman’s Trauma and Recovery remains one of the clearest guides. Herman starts with our history of forgetting. Hysteria in the late nineteenth century, shell shock after the First World War, combat neurosis, and the violence done to women and children in private life: each was discovered, studied, and then pushed out of view again. Her argument is that trauma is hard to think about not only because it is painful, but because it implicates the rest of us.

What trauma is
Herman describes traumatic events as those that “overwhelm the ordinary human adaptations to life.” The emphasis falls less on the event than on what it does. The usual ways of coping, fighting back, getting away, asking for help, making sense of things, stop working. The person is left helpless in the face of something they cannot stop.
At the centre of her account are two experiences: disempowerment and disconnection. Trauma takes away a person’s sense that they have any effect on what happens to them. It also ruptures the bonds with others that ordinarily hold a self together. Basic assumptions about safety, about whether other people can be relied on, and about the meaning of one’s own life are shaken or broken.
Psychoanalytic writers have added a further dimension. Trauma is not only what happened, but what could not be taken in, thought about, or shared with someone at the time. Dori Laub described trauma as an event that had no witness, including no inner witness. The mind had no way to hold it, so it is stored differently: in fragments, in the body, in action, rather than as a story that can be told.
What trauma isn’t
Not every painful experience is traumatic. Grief, disappointment, conflict, rejection, the ordinary failures of parents, the stress of work or illness: these can hurt badly and shape a life without overwhelming the mind’s capacity to process them. The difference is not how much something hurts, or whether it matters. It is whether the experience could eventually be felt and thought about, or whether it broke through and stayed unprocessed.
A few other distinctions are worth making.
• Trauma is not the same as PTSD. PTSD is one diagnostic description of one pattern of response. Many people carry the effects of trauma without meeting its criteria, and the diagnosis says little about relational or developmental injury.
• Trauma is not defined by the event alone. The same event may be traumatic for one person and not another, depending on age, earlier experience, what support was available, and what the event meant.
• Trauma is not an identity or a life sentence. Herman is clear that recovery is possible, though it is rarely linear and rarely complete in a tidy way.
• Trauma is not a word for discomfort. The psychologist Nick Haslam has written about “concept creep,” the gradual widening of terms like trauma and abuse. The widening comes from a decent impulse. But it can blur what is specific about overwhelming experience, and it can leave people believing that ordinary difficulty is something they cannot survive.

Different kinds of trauma
These categories overlap, and most people who come to therapy carry more than one. They are useful less as labels than as ways of noticing where an injury came from and what shape it has taken.
Single-incident (episodic) trauma
A discrete event: an assault, an accident, a natural disaster, a sudden death witnessed. Before it, life was going one way; after it, something has changed. Herman’s account of hyperarousal, intrusion and constriction, described below, fits these experiences closely. When there was a reasonably secure life before the event, there is often a self to return to, even if the way back is hard.
Relational trauma
Injury that happens inside relationships a person depends on, most often in childhood: neglect, emotional abuse, a parent who was frightening or frightened, chronic misattunement, being made responsible for a parent’s feelings. It is often less visible than an event. People who carry it frequently say that nothing really happened. What happened was the repeated experience of needing someone who was also the source of distress, or who was not there.
Complex or chronic trauma
This is Herman’s most important point. She noticed that people subjected to prolonged, repeated trauma looked different from people who had survived a single event, especially when the trauma happened under conditions of captivity, where escape was not possible. Captivity here includes childhood in an abusive family, domestic violence and coercive control, trafficking, and political imprisonment.
The effects reach beyond the familiar PTSD symptoms into changes in emotional regulation, in consciousness and memory, and in the sense of self, often as pervasive shame or a feeling of being fundamentally different from others. Relationships, and the systems of meaning a person lives by, are affected too. So, often, is the relationship to the perpetrator, which can involve preoccupation, idealization, or taking on their view of oneself. Complex PTSD is now recognized in the World Health Organization’s ICD-11, though not in the DSM.
Vicarious trauma
The effect on people repeatedly exposed to others’ traumatic experience: therapists, physicians, first responders, journalists, lawyers, and family members of survivors. Herman writes candidly about how therapists can come to share the survivor’s helplessness, rage and despair, and how this can push them toward over-rescuing, withdrawal, or disbelief. Her response is that no one should do this work alone.
Intergenerational trauma
Trauma that was not lived directly but was passed down: through a parent’s unprocessed experience, family silences, parenting shaped by fear, or the collective histories of war, genocide, displacement, colonization and slavery. Selma Fraiberg’s “Ghosts in the Nursery” described how a parent’s unremembered childhood pain can be re-enacted with their own baby. Haydée Faimberg wrote about the telescoping of generations, in which a child carries a history that belongs to a parent or grandparent.
Often what is transmitted is not a story but a gap: an atmosphere, an anxiety with no obvious source, something that is not spoken about. There is also research on biological transmission, including Rachel Yehuda’s work with the children of Holocaust survivors, though the epigenetic findings are still debated.
Signs and symptoms
Herman groups the core symptoms into three categories.
Hyperarousal. The nervous system stays on alert, as if the danger might return at any moment. This shows up as a strong startle response, irritability, poor sleep, trouble concentrating, and a body that cannot settle.
Intrusion. The traumatic moment returns uninvited, in flashbacks, nightmares, sudden images, sensations or smells. Herman notes that traumatic memories are often stored without the verbal, contextual narrative of ordinary memory. They come back as vivid fragments, frozen in time, and can feel as though they are happening now rather than being remembered.
Constriction. The opposite movement: numbing, detachment, avoidance, a narrowing of life. Dissociation belongs here, the sense of watching oneself from outside, losing time, or feeling unreal. So does the use of alcohol or other substances to stay numb.
These states alternate. A person swings between being flooded and being shut down, and neither state allows the experience to be integrated. Herman calls this the dialectic of trauma.
Quieter signs
In the consulting room, trauma often shows itself less through a checklist of symptoms than through the texture of how someone speaks and relates.
• Blurting. Traumatic material can come out suddenly: early in a first meeting, at the end of a session as the person is leaving, or in a flat voice that does not match what is being said. This is not oversharing in the usual sense. The material has not been worked into a story that can be paced, so it breaks through rather than being told. Afterward people often feel exposed or ashamed, and unsure why they said it.
• Fragmented or contradictory accounts. Herman points out that survivors’ stories can have gaps, reversals and inconsistencies. These are often read as unreliability. They are better understood as the mark of experience that was never fully integrated.
• A mismatch of feeling. Describing something terrible with a smile, or with no feeling at all, and then being overwhelmed by something that seems small.
• Minimizing. “It wasn’t that bad.” “Other people had it worse.” Sometimes this protects an attachment. Sometimes it protects the person from knowing what happened.
• Shame more than fear. With relational and complex trauma especially, the dominant feeling is often a conviction of being bad, damaged or different.
• The body. Chronic tension, pain, or other physical symptoms without a clear medical explanation.
• Trouble with time. The past does not feel past, and the future is hard to imagine.
What a list of symptoms leaves out
A list of symptoms describes what trauma looks like from the outside, at a given moment. It misses a great deal. Trauma also shapes the way a person trusts, loves, fights and asks for help, often in ways they cannot see. It tends to repeat itself in relationships, including the relationship with a therapist. Part 2 looks at how that happens, and at how psychoanalytic psychotherapy works with it.
Interested in working together?
The first step is to complete our intake form so we can match you with the right therapist. After we review your information, your therapist will reach out to arrange a 20‑minute consultation.
Taking care of your mental health is a courageous and important step towards overall well-being. We're here to support you on your journey to a happier, healthier life.
Read More:
This post reflects my own clinical perspective and is intended for informational purposes only. If you’re navigating trauma—of any kind—please work with a qualified clinician who can take the time to understand your specific history and needs.



Comments